real estate lawyer

Role of Attorney in Real Estate Litigation in Arizona - Gottlieb Law

The Role of a Real Estate Attorney in Litigation: Insights and Expectations

The Role of a Real Estate Attorney in Litigation: Insights and Expectations 2141 1200 Gottlieb Law

Understanding complexities of real estate transactions and disputes requires not just an understanding of the law, but an adeptness at leveraging it to one’s advantage. This is where the significance of a real estate lawyer comes into play. 

With clauses and contingencies dotting every contract and the potential for disputes looming from deeds of trust to property title, the experience of a seasoned real estate lawyer is invaluable. These professionals ensure legality, represent interests in litigations, and guide through the intricacies of real estate law, making them indispensable in safeguarding assets and rights. 

One might wonder, what exactly is the role of a real estate lawyer? Their scope extends beyond mere transaction facilitation—encompassing everything from contract drafting to probate litigation, acting as both shield and spear in the legal arena of real estate.

Exploring the Dynamics of Real Estate Legal Disputes

Real estate litigation spans a broad spectrum of conflicts pertaining to property and real estate dealings. These disputes can arise from various situations, including disagreements over property boundaries, breaches of real estate contracts, or landlord-tenant conflicts. The complexity of the litigation process, involving numerous legal principles and regulations, necessitates a clear comprehension of what real estate litigation entails to navigate such situations effectively.

Differences between Litigation and Standard Real Estate Transactions

Transactional practice in real estate involves the creation and review of documents that facilitate the transfer of interests in land or property between parties, such as buyers and sellers or lessors and lessees. This collaborative process is characterized by research, drafting contracts, and participating in closings, with a focus on business and corporate issues affecting clients. 

In contrast, litigation is the resolution of disputes, often in a courtroom setting, and is adversarial in nature. Litigators engage when a lawsuit may be required, focusing on resolving disputes that arise from real estate transactions.

Common Causes Leading to Real Estate Litigation

Several common causes can lead to real estate litigation, including:

  • Failure to Disclose Property Defects: It is imperative for sellers to disclose any known flaws or defects that could impact the value of the property. Neglecting to do so may result in legal recourse being taken against the seller.
  • Breach of Contract: If one party fails to adhere to the stipulations outlined in a real estate agreement, the opposing party reserves the right to pursue legal action for breach of contract.
  • Breach of Duty or Negligence: Real estate agents may face legal action for negligence or breach of duty if they do not prioritize their clients’ best interests.
  • Boundary Dispute: Disputes regarding property boundaries can escalate into legal battles, particularly when the recorded property boundaries are inaccurate or differ from the practical boundaries recognized by residents.
  • Zoning Disputes: Disputes concerning land utilization and zoning regulations can evolve into intricate affairs, encompassing the procedures for securing or contesting zoning rulings or permits.

Understanding these common causes and the differences between transactional practice and litigation is crucial for property owners, real estate professionals, and legal practitioners navigating the real estate market.

The Role of a Real Estate Attorney

Real estate litigation encompasses a variety of complex legal challenges that require the experience and touch of skilled attorneys. Arizona real estate attorneys are adept at understanding sophisticated deal financing, ownership structures, and the specific regulations that govern real estate transactions. Their knowledge is crucial in navigating the intricacies of the industry, whether representing clients in state and federal courts or alternative dispute resolution forums. Attorneys handle a wide range of issues from contractual disputes to restructuring financial obligations and asset management, providing holistic solutions that address clients’ needs comprehensively.

Negotiating Settlements

A significant aspect of a real estate attorney’s role involves negotiating settlements to resolve disputes without the need for lengthy litigation. Using persuasive negotiation techniques, attorneys work to achieve favorable outcomes that align with their clients’ interests. By focusing discussions on strengths and anchoring settlement proposals to advantageous comparisons, they effectively persuade the opposition. This calculated approach not only conserves time and resources but also mitigates potential risks stemming from uncertainties in trial proceedings.

Representing Clients in Court

When litigation is unavoidable, real estate attorneys provide robust representation in court proceedings. They prepare and present compelling legal arguments, advocate for their clients’ positions, and navigate through the complexities of courtroom procedures. Their proficiency in real estate law equips them to manage a wide spectrum of issues, ranging from breach of contract instances to disagreements regarding property appraisal. By collaborating with appraisers and experts, they strengthen their clients’ cases and ensure that their rights and financial interests are vigorously defended.

Key Stages of Real Estate Litigation

From pre-litigation negotiations and initial pleadings to discovery, motion practice, and trial, this guide navigates through the complex terrain of real estate litigation, providing insights into the strategies, procedures, and legal principles that shape the outcome of disputes. 

Initial Consultation and Case Evaluation

It all kicks off with that crucial first meet-up: the initial consultation and case evaluation with an experienced Arizona real estate attorney. Think of it as your legal roadmap, laying out the terrain ahead. 

Here’s where the wheels start turning—documents like the summons, complaint, and petitions get filed with the County Clerk. Now, it’s not just about stacking papers. You’ll grab a case number, sort out the filing fees, and if you’re filing electronically, you’ll follow some precise steps to make sure everything’s buttoned up and filed electronically without a hitch. Note that some courts require in-person filings.  This phase isn’t just procedural; it’s foundational, setting the legal stage for the complexities of the litigation journey you’re about to navigate.

Discovery and Pre-Trial Motions

Following the initial filings, the discovery phase commences, where both parties exchange crucial information to build their cases. This stage involves filing motions and discovery, including requests for admissions, requests for production of documents, and interrogatories.  Preliminary legal motions, such as requests for summary judgment or dismissal, hold significant sway in steering the trajectory of litigation, potentially resolving matters prior to trial.

Trial and Post-Trial Actions

The culmination of the litigation process is the trial, where the matters at hand are presented and argued before a judge or jury. Following the trial, post-trial actions are crucial for addressing any discrepancies or legal errors identified during proceedings. Parties have the opportunity to file motions to alter the jury’s verdict or to appeal the decision, which involves submitting detailed arguments to higher courts to reassess the case. This stage is essential for ensuring justice is served, based on the merits of the case and adherence to legal standards.

Challenges and Considerations in Real Estate Litigation

Real estate litigation presents a unique set of challenges and considerations that can significantly impact all parties involved. From the time investment to the emotional strain, understanding these aspects is crucial for anyone navigating this complex legal terrain. 


  • Process: Real estate litigation can be time consuming, with cases stretching over months or even years. This extended duration can be frustrating for some litigants.  In other cases, a pretrial motion can be sought and granted which ends the litigation.  
  • Settlement Encouragement: Courts and counsel often encourage settlement to avoid the unpredictability of trial outcomes. This can be a double-edged sword, pressuring parties into agreements that may not fully serve their interests. Under Arizona law, attorneys fees may be awarded by the Court for prevailing in certain cases, so settlement is not necessarily always an ideal option if the settlement terms are unfavorable and the case is strong.

Impact on Property Value and Ownership

  • Depreciation or Appreciation in Property Value: Litigation can tarnish the reputation of a property, leading to a decrease in its market value. This rings especially true in cases of high visibility or those entailing substantial structural or safety concerns.  On the other hand, it may become necessary to litigate to remove an encroachment against the property.
  • Ownership Uncertainty: Disputes over property lines, ownership rights, or contractual obligations can create uncertainty around property ownership pending 

Real estate legal battles encompass a diverse array of conflicts, each presenting its unique set of hurdles and factors to consider. From the financial and temporal costs to the emotional toll and impact on property value, these factors underscore the importance of skilled legal representation. A real estate attorney can navigate these complexities, advocating for their client’s interests while striving for the most favorable resolution.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the myriad challenges showcased, ranging from the challenges of litigation to the impacts on property value, highlights the significance of adept legal representation. Real estate litigation demands a strategic and well-informed approach, underscoring the importance of engaging with attorneys who are not just knowledgeable but deeply invested in achieving favorable outcomes for their clients. In this light, the insights provided serve as a crucial resource for anyone navigating the complexities of real estate transactions and disputes.

Gottlieb Law Can Represent Your Interest in an Arizona Real Estate Dispute

Our team of experienced Arizona real estate lawyers is committed to protecting your assets and rights during conflicts. Whether you’re facing contractual conflicts, property boundary disagreements, or other legal complexities, we’re here to provide strategic counsel and vigorous representation. Contact us today at 602-899-8188 or use our contact us page here to discuss your real estate litigation needs and discover how Gottlieb Law can help you achieve favorable outcomes.

Gottlieb Law, PLC provides this article for information purposes only and nothing herein creates an attorney-client relationship.  You should not take any actions in reliance on any of the information contained herein without consulting with qualified legal counsel first and reading this article is not a proper substitute for seeking legal advice of your specific situation.